Shingle Meeting Agenda April 18, 2008 at Gary Reinecke’s Home
Attendees were Dick Merrill, Ralph Kloiber, Gary Reinecke, Cindy Pedersen and Greg Chismar.
- Resolve who will pay for re-work of roofs with Barkwood Natural Shadow shingles at 2332 and 2334 Lehman lane.
- Greg said GAF was waiting for the outcome of this meeting and had made no commitments.
- Greg had found some of the original shingles and we looked at them next to the Weathered Wood HD. Greg claims he did the best he could to get a match. Our position is that the Weathered Wood HD shingles have a very different look when on the roof than the original shingles.
- We reiterated that when GAF and Elk merged they changed the product line. Elk had made the HD style and have a patent on it. GAF had produced the Natural Shadow. We also stated that we were told the formulations had changed. The Weathered wood HD is close in matching colors but the HD feature gives the shingle a very different look.
- If GAF failed to let Greg know about the change and that it was not exactly the same then they should have some responsibility to cover the rework.
- The MADWA board asked Greg to go back to GAF on Monday and negotiate for the entire cost of replacing the two roofs.
- Furnace vent replacements with matching colors of shingles?
- A can of spray paint is used to paint the furnace vents.
- We decided that this might be a maintenance issue if the paint started to chip or peel so decided to leave the furnace vents as is.
- Exterior work – when and color matching.
- Need to be sure that any gutters and/or fascia replaced runs the entire length of the side being replaced.
- Not all sides are being replaced so there may be a color match from side to side.
- Need to see samples of gutters and Fascia before any installation.
- Resolution of partial roof replacements:
- 2355 – O Brian (50%)
- 2361 – Russell (50%)
- 2373 – Reinecke (50%)
- Our understanding is that partials are not done anymore.
- Need to get in touch with Al Holland and determine if there is a State Law about not doing partial roofs.
- Then need Greg to go up on the roof and mark damaged areas.
- Then need to get the insurance adjuster back out.
- The amount to complete the above roofs is $19,676.55